| Author |
Topic: Wacker oxidation using cheap inorganic
reagents? |
rev
drone Member |
posted 08-01-99 03:27 AM
Now alkyl nitrites have been used by many bees quite successfully as
oxidizing reagents in the Wacker oxidation of safrole, but what about
other, even simpler nitrite-containing species? For that matter, what
about reducable inorganics in general?
Rather than using a nitrite ester, what about a nitrite salt? Sodium,
potassium, or ammonium nitrite all have seemingl the same reducing
potential as thier esterified counterpart, or do they?
So would this work, or is there some wierd orbital overlap (or lack of
wierd overlap) that would keep this reeaction from proceeding? There are
examples galore of nitrite species present without adverse affects on
palladium-catalyzed oxidations, but is the electron withdrawing presence
of an alkyl group attached to the nitrite really needed to get it to do
what we want?
Likewise, what about sulfur-based oxidizing reagents, like something as
simple as sulfate salts? Unfortunately, my CRC handbook isn't nearby, but
it seems that the redox potentials for many of these compounds are within
reason for them to be looked at as potential oxidizing reagents with the
Wacker.
The beauty of these methods is that they could combine affordability
that pressurized O2 offers, with the convenience of a homogeneous system
that more expensive reagets such as benzoquinone have. Theoretically, by
judicious use of PTC's, any solubility issues could be taken care of.
So what do people think?
------------------ -the good reverend drone
|
ymir Member |
posted 08-01-99 11:02 AM
Interesting, was looking at a book on oxidations while locating those
other references. Didn't copy the reference, but it was mentioned that
mercury salts could promote a Wacker type oxidation of a terminal olefin.
Probably is more in the local library as well. Will get back after
locating the track.
|
hellman Member |
posted 08-02-99 01:04 AM
I guess as long as the sodium doesn't interfere with the olefin, which it
probably wouldn't,. Imagine that, using sodium nitrite, and the final
ketone is completely turned into the addition product, you know IT JUST
MIGHT WORK,
Maybee it's a job for that guy in the black tights.
'the curtains dissolve, as the last remnents of sanity has been lazily
scraped from the cold wooden stage floor, as the crowed settles into it's
seats. Into the bowl, the masked man places 100ml of his olefinic
com-par-dree, along with 120 g of sodium's favourite nitrite, and 300ml
IPA just for good measure, the parsleys this time was purposly left out,
but not so for the unlucky black pepper of pipperonis. It boiled like a
pot on the stove for three hours, the masked man checked the pot once
every five minutes, to find that, mistakingly he was watching the wrong
pot. All was well though,. Off he then took the saucepot lid, to let
this now quiet muther fucker, evap to dryness, upon which he was left with
44g of a white oily chicken fat looking substance, which was washed with
toluene, not just to clean it, but as to ensure freshness, Which
eventually gave the quite happy Black tight scoundrel 35g of pure extacy,.
He believed it was extacy, as he had a predisposition to psyco-somatic
symptoms,
hell, for a days work, he was more than pissed
hellman
|
Cherrie
Baby Member |
posted 08-02-99 02:26 PM
Not so easy. I think that it would have to be done with a Pd complex which
was soluble in the organic layer. Extracting the oxidising source into the
organic layer is easy. But you have to find a suitable method of getting
Pd to stay in the organic layer rather than the aqueous.
Otherwise you could try a reverse-PTC. Extracting safrole into the
aqueous layer.
|
ymir Member |
posted 08-02-99 05:10 PM
Unfortunately, the reference is one well known to the Hive, the
problemetical mercuric acetate oxidation method. One piece of perhaps
useful information that turned up was two mechanisms for the oxidations of
a terminal olefin to a ketone: Removal of hydride ion resulting in an
allylic free radical or oxidation at the double bond leading to a ketol
derivative, which dehydrates to the ketone. How the man in black got a
bisulfite addition product from boiling a terminal olefin in sodium
nitrite/IPA is some what unclear. Did the man in black isolate an organic
layer, and then treat that with sodium bisulfite, or was distillation
required, etc., etc.?
|
rev
drone Member |
posted 08-02-99 08:02 PM
Cherrie Baby,
Actually, it is that easy; for PdCl2, the solibility partitiion greatly
favors DCM over H2O. For more solvent choices, look under some of the more
recent titles covering precious metal recovery: this is increasingly the
choice of industry.
------------------ -the good reverend drone
|
Osmium Member |
posted 08-03-99 11:56 AM
I disagree with the ox. potential of the inorganic nitrites. I don't think
that it will be high enough in aq. solution. To be of any value, it must
be quite acidic, a condition which is not too favorable with the Wacker
(could be wrong on this one, but I don't think so).
|
rev
drone Member |
posted 08-05-99 06:17 PM
Os,
This is exactly what I wanted to discuss. To be honest, I can't say
with certainty that it would work, but that's why I started this thread.
I'd be very interested in hearing why EXACTLY you feel that nitrites
wouldn't work without low pH's. Do you have any good information sources
backing you on this?
------------------ -the good reverend drone
|
Osmium Member |
posted 08-06-99 04:50 AM
No, but I have a ref which proves me wrong,
which is ok for me. And before anybody else does it, I'll post it myself.
JOC 1990, 55, 2924-27
A benzo-Wacker with added acids, like HClO4, HBF4, HNO3. Solvent aq.
MeCN, yields >90%, finished in 10mins. 50 times faster than a
comparable Wacker without added acids. So acids are indeed compatible with
the wacker, at least with this one. They even speed it up! Only ten
minutes to completion! Do it in a tubular reactor, and you have a
continuous process for ketone production.
|
rev
drone Member |
posted 08-06-99 06:15 AM
Os,
Wow! I suppose the acids do a nice job homogeneously regenerating the
oxidized Pd species (Pd being the "least noble" of the precious metals, it
doesn't hesitate to react with HNO3, or even HCl in the right conditions.)
One of the nice things about Pd catalysts is the very fact that, among
the precious metals used as redox catalysts, its the only one that really
stands up to acidic conditions and stil does its job. Off to the library I
go!
|
rev
drone Member |
posted 08-07-99 01:19 PM
Os,
How would you suggest engineering this into process?
------------------ -the good reverend drone
|
rev
drone Member |
posted 08-07-99 01:22 PM
Argh! That should read: "How would you suggest engineering this into a
continuous process?"
|
rev
drone Member |
posted 08-07-99 06:24 PM
Now here' the next question: are we looking at nitration as a side
reaction? According to Rhodium, nitric acid, even without the presence of
an activator like H2SO4, will nitrate the benzodioxole, as it is activated
on its own, due to the electron dontation from the two oxygens. I'd like
so see evidense of that, but maybe he has a point. I'll dig around my
library, but somehow I feel this side reation can be kept to a minemum by
keeping the concentrations of available NO2+ low.
------------------ -the good reverend drone
|
Rhodium Administrator |
posted 08-08-99 10:04 AM
Perhaps I should add that the observation I referred to involved chilled
concentrated nitric acid (compare the nitration of 2C-H to 2C-N in
Pihkal). Just a little HNO3 or HNO2 in the solution probably won't nitrate
the ring.
|
Osmium Member |
posted 08-09-99 05:57 AM
A long thin SS pipe, coiled up to conserve space, is used as the tubular
reactor. The ingredients are continuously introduced, pushing the reaction
mix slowly through the pipe. At the end, the now finished reaction is
worked up batchwise, as usual, or with an improved procedure (flashing
away the acetonitrile for reuse, flooding with water, extraction etc).
Drone, forget HNO3. It nitrates or activated benzenes instantly, that's
what you learn in basic organic chemistry lectures. Or from the buddy in
school who is into pyro/explosives.
|